Fish of a Lifetime

My first Mahi Mahi! (Also called dolphinfish or dorado)

I’ve been waiting five and a half months to catch a Mahi Mahi, and the first day at sea we hooked up to a 20lb, 3.5’ long cow Mahi! 

We were trolling a 4” cedar plug on a handline around 100’ behind Flyer, and a blue chugger with a hoochie under it on our Shimano TLD 50 reel on an Ugly Stik rod. Back in La Paz, there was a boat that pulled in that had a guy who was really knowledgeable about Mahi fishing and told us to run that exact lure behind the boat while trolling.

The second the fish hooked up, we saw it jumping like a marlin about 200 feet behind the boat, and it was all blue!

Mahi are my favorite fish because they are insanely hard to fight. They also change colors! They can be chartreuse, blue, and white! They might even show black spots.

My dad and I had to take turns reeling it in because it was spooling our reel. At the time, we were sailing along in about 28 knots of wind at about 8 knots- it was a real sleigh ride! We tried to slow the boat down by furling the jib, but it didn’t help too much. After about 25 minutes of fighting, we finally got it to the boat and my dad gaffed it about half way across its body and we hoisted aboard.

Getting close!
It was mostly yellow in the water
Dad using the gaffe

We tried to ike-jime it (a Japanese technique that helps the meat taste better and last longer in the fridge), but it was really hard to figure out where to insert the metal rod. We bled the fish and took some photos – a lot of photos!

Now it was looking mostly blue
It was really hard to pick up!

Sport Fish of the Pacific lists the food value of Mahi as “none better.”Pelle got sushi for dinner and we filled the refrigerator with Mahi fillets!


Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Comments

8 responses to “Fish of a Lifetime”

  1. Celi Putnam Avatar
    Celi Putnam

    Congratulations to Paul! Sushi for Pelle and fillets dressed in the fridge..what could be better and well deserved ( 25 long minutes « sleigh ride » wow!) Bon appétit for many fine entrées.

    Celi

  2. Brittnie, Esme, and Minha Avatar
    Brittnie, Esme, and Minha

    Paul this is so awesome. We are all so excited for you and so jealous about the mahi you’ll get to eat. Miss you tons!!!

  3. David Pierson Avatar
    David Pierson

    Wonderful job, Paul!! Providing fun and food for the crew, and Pele.

  4. Marcia & John Avatar
    Marcia & John

    Congratulations Paul! We loved reading about your wonderful catch … what a great experience! Am sure Pelle will be expecting more Mahi Sushi!

  5. Jim Buttrick Avatar
    Jim Buttrick

    Congratulations Paul!!

  6. Rich Grutzmacher Avatar
    Rich Grutzmacher

    Incredible Paul! So awesome. I love reading your posts. Write more!

  7. Paul Avatar
    Paul

    Outstanding! What a story. Great work landing a beautiful catch!

  8. Auntie Amy F. Avatar

    “it was a real sleigh ride!” Paul, I adore your parents and their writing, but please, please start doing more posts! If I’m not mistaken, this is your first, and I absolutely loved it. I’m also very impressed with how much you know about sailing… I felt like I was reading a different language for the majority of this post after you caught the mahi mahi. Congratulations! Very nice work. Beautiful and looks delicious!! — [Auntie] Amy

    PS: greetings from snow-covered Beacon, NY!

Leave a Reply to Marcia & JohnCancel reply